Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

NWPStaging

:

MainDB: Pro-poor analysis of REDD+ activities in the Yucatan Peninsula

Title

Pro-poor analysis of REDD+ activities in the Yucatan Peninsula

NWPWeblink

 

NWPTypeOfOrganization

Civil society

NWPGeographicRegion

North America

Scope of work

 

NWPMandatesandFrameworks

 

NWPModalityApproachandMechanism

 

NWPEffortsToAddressSOE

 

NWPRelevantStakeholders

 

NWPFocusonNElossesFlag

 

NWPImpactAreas

 

NWPOutputs

 

Good practices and lessons learned

  • ​​The limitation of REDD+’s contribution to poverty alleviation in the Yucatan Peninsula is that it is not the local poor who are causing carbon emissions, but primarily better-off groups. Hence it is probable that compensation for reduced emissions will in the first instance target the less poor, thus increasing income gaps between the poor and better-off groups. 
  • An initial condition to promote a pro-poor approach to benefit sharing is to involve vulnerable groups in this planning process. REDD+ interventions should include individuals, households, and collective groups.
  • Activities increasing the productivity of subsistence farming without increasing forest degradation could benefit a large number of the relatively poor.​
  • Enhanced local management and governance would benefit all, including the poor.
  • Subsidies focusing on households (rather than collectively through representatives of local communities, as it is common practice in some programmes) and not requiring land rights (as is the case with many agricultural subsidies) can benefit poorer groups more effectively.

NWPGapsChallenges

 

Date of submission

 

Abbreviation

 

Activities

 

Adaptation element

Adaptation planning and practices; Institutional arrangements; Knowledge management; Science and research; Stakeholder involvement

Adaptation sector/theme

Agriculture; Biodiversity

Climate hazard

Land and forest degradation; Loss of biodiversity

Country

Mexico

NWPDataSource

 

Description

The objective of this study is to evaluate the potential for pro-poor REDD+ benefit sharing in the region known as Yucatan Peninsula (comprising the states of Campeche, Quintana Roo and Yucatan) in Mexico, considering the prevalent drivers of deforestation and forest degradation and the possible alternatives to address them, and assessing the impacts of each of these strategies on different local social groups. The evaluation of these impacts is based on a brief description of the livelihoods and living standards of different social groups of rural communities. The analyses presented here consider the identification of local poorer groups and their prototypical involvement in the main drivers of emissions and potential engagement in REDD+ activities. 

Expected outcome

 

Further information

NWPGeographicScope

Subregional

Indicators of achievement

 

NWPInformationType

Case study

NWPJoinDate

06/08/2021

NWPPartner

International Union for Conservation of Nature

Purpose

 

Regional group

 

Target group

Academics and scientists; Policy makers; Practitioners

NWPWorkStream

NWP

NWPYear

 

NWPOutcome

The information generated can be used as “cross-reference” tools for the analysis and the design of pro-poor interventions that can be replicated and adapted to a specific condition. A pro-poor approach implies that REDD+ benefits flow to both the poorer and the better-off groups of rural areas. If REDD+ activities are to be pro-poor they would have to improve productivity, technology transfer, and access to markets for poorer groups. These actions will add economic value to sustainable practices allowing reinvestment and recapitalization. 

The preparation of climate-effective land use plans can be particularly beneficial for the poor if they receive access to land, if collective parcels are defined or if they are included in economic activities. The household is the smallest and most critical economic organizational unit in rural economies where decisions on how to allocate labor and other resources are made; it is also the primary institution and safety network in rural economies, particularly for the poor. It will be difficult for REDD+ to prevent long-term decapitalis​ation linked to land sales given its voluntary nature and large opportunity costs. Nevertheless, strengthening social capital at the household scale and financing sustainable development plans may reduce this process, particularly if REDD+ is able to promote the inclusion of social and environmental values and costs in supply chains and industries, the financial sector, and consumer behavior.

NWPPartners

 

Type of knowledge resource

 

Scale of work

 

NWPSlowOnsetEvents

 

NWPReferences

Balderas Torres, A., Skutsch, M. and de los Rios Ibarra, E. (2020). Pro-poor analysis of REDD+ activities in the Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. Technical Series: Forest Governance and Economics, No. 8. San Jose, Costa Rica: IUCN and CIGA. xvii + 125pp. Available at: https://portals.iucn.org/library/node/49249

Implementing partners

Centro de Investigaciones en Geografía Ambiental (CIGA) of UNAM. Conducting data collection and analysis.

NWPYearPublication

 

NWPUpdate

 

SourceItemID

2179

NWPSecendaryEmail

 

NWPPrimaryEmail

 

NWPTypeOfKnowledge

Technical document/report

NWPCountryItem

 

NWPRelevantWeblinks

 

Attachments

Content Type: NWPSearchableItem
Created at 06/08/2021 16:16 by crmmocservices
Last modified at 16/05/2022 09:10 by Lilian Daphine Lunyolo